It is with a heavy heart, but a definite optimism, that we bid farewell to Scarlet Spider, the little comic that almost could. How is it even possible that Marvel took a chance on a comic so deeply indebted to the despised Clone Saga? A comic starring Kaine, of all characters, going by the name ‘Scarlet Spider’, of all names? Sheer lunacy! But writer Christopher Yost made it happen, and through 25 issues, he gave us a pretty darn good comic book. This final issue is, in some ways, a wrap up of Kaine’s adventure in Houston. But it’s just as much a prologue for what comes next in New Warriors.

Scarlet Spider #25

Scarlet Spider #25 is a good finale. The art is back to its usual strength, and Yost gives us a pretty epic battle with which to say goodbye. There isn’t too much soul searching or finality, but this comic is a pretty solid look into the life of the failed clone of Spider-Man.

Comic Rating: 8/10 – Very Good.

I think Kaine is a character with a lot of potential, and it’s a simple potential. Just like the banner read at the start of this series: ‘All the power, none of the responsibility.’ He’s not the anti-Spider-Man, he’s Spider-Man’s neglected kid brother. That has potential. Spider-Man is this great hero, well respected in the superhero community, beloved by many beautiful women, adored by his loving Aunt May and all-in-all, lives a pretty OK life (other than this Otto Octavius stuff, of course). Kaine is the guy living in Peter Parker’s shadow. Kaine didn’t ask for this life. He didn’t choose to give himself spider-powers. He was born into Peter Parker’s shadow, and he isn’t using that to become some kind of heartless, evil villain who just wants to make Peter miserable – like the reveal of Thomas Wayne Jr. as the head of the Court of Owls over in Scott Snyder’s Batman.

And therein, I think, lies part of the problem with Scarlet Spider the series. And why I think DC’s new Harley Quinn series isn’t going to last long: when you remove these characters from the context in which they are most interesting, giving them instead a generic superhero set up, it robs their story of its maximum appeal. Kaine may be an entertaining guy, but I most want to read about Kaine in the context of the rest of the Spider-verse. What do the Avengers think about Kaine? What do Mary Jane and Aunt May think about Kaine? How does Peter deal with having his adversarial clone healthy and alive? I loved the scenes at the end of Spider-Island where the two of them had to work together. Why couldn’t we have a comic about that?

Removing Kaine (or Harley Quinn) from that which defines them is going to make the comic a tougher sell. This is a cruel market, and as you can see, Scarlet Spider just didn’t last.

Hopefully, New Warriors will learn some lessons from Scarlet Spider. Kaine will be interacting with the larger Marvel Universe, with people who will compare him to Spider-Man. Therein lies the best drama, I think. Not that Kaine’s adventure in Houston wasn’t thoroughly entertaining. I would say this was a quaint but forgettable series, hopefully a springboard to launch Kaine into bigger and better adventures.

Join me after the jump for a full synopsis and more review!

Read the rest of this entry →

The end of Scarlet Spider will soon be upon us, and apparently writer Christopher Yost wants to go out with a bang – literally. No, seriously, there’s a big explosion at the end. In fact, this whole penultimate issue is like a big explosion. The writing of cancellation has been on the wall for some time, so Yost has had plenty of time to prepare for these last two issues. The action and drama get pushed up to 11 as Yost seems to throw everything he can into the issue, including the kitchen sink. Storylines that he probably planned for future arcs get crammed into this one issue. Yost seems determined to blow our minds with this finale. If only the art was willing to do the same.

Scarlet Spider #24

Scarlet Spider #24 may be the beginning of the end, but writer Christopher Yost is not yet ready to say goodbye – and we are all the better for it.

Comic Rating: 7/10 – Good.

From the very start, we all knew this was coming. The editors even acknowledge as much on the last page, saying their goodbyes now so that Yost can say his goodbyes in the last issue. The comic book industry these days just doesn’t support this kind of comic. Reaching the 20s in a solo series about a D-list character (at best) is a rare feat, and something to be proud of. Fearless Defenders, a comic launched under the promise of Marvel’s first all-female team, was cancelled this week with issue #12. That’s as far as they made it. But Scarlet Spider, a comic starring Kaine from the much-hated Clone Saga, made it to issue #25. That’s impressive.

I think what did the series in was the fact that it was still just a generic superhero story. Sure, Kaine is kind of an asshole, but this was still a comic about a guy with powers and a costume, who sets up shop to fight crime and super-villains, with a wacky band of supporting characters to play with. New solo comics like Hawkeye succeed because they’re doing something new and interesting with the superhero angle. Scarlet Spider was too much like the norm, starring a character that general audiences didn’t care about. So while it’s sad to see the series, go, there’s no denying it never had much of a chance.

Fortunately, like I said, this penultimate issue is pretty entertaining. Yost has nothing more to lose, so join me after the jump to dig into this exciting, action-packed issue!

Read the rest of this entry →

I wonder if, when all is said and done, the theme of this Scarlet Spider series is going to be ‘failure’. I don’t mean that to be rude, because I’m a huge Scarlet Spider fan and I’ve really enjoyed this comic. But surely everybody going in had to know it probably wouldn’t last. There just isn’t a big enough fan base for the character to warrant several years of publication. New comics these days are lucky to last two years, and I’m grateful that we made it all the way into the 20s. But writer Christopher Yost had to have known his run would have an ending, and I wonder if he planned from the beginning on having Kaine fail as a superhero.

Scarlet Spider #23

It would be a bold stance on a series like this. Not everybody is destined to be the world’s greatest hero, and maybe a sadsack like Kaine just couldn’t cut it. If his final battle with Kraven is any indication, maybe he just doesn’t have what it takes.

Comic Rating: 7/10 – Good.

The final battle between Kaine and Kraven is upon us, and it lives up to almost all expectations. Yost has been building this one for awhile, and I’m excited to see Kaine throw down with an established Marvel super-villain. He may be a second-stringer like Kraven, but at least he’s got the chops to be devastating. And Yost makes the stakes pretty damn high, with all of Kaine’s friends on the chopping block. But for all the fun of this final confrontation, I don’t think Yost went far enough. In the end, Scarlet Spider is still just a second-stringer itself, and it’s so close to cancellation that it just doesn’t matter. So Yost just couldn’t deliver as deeply tragic or as powerful an issue as I would have liked.

I would have hoped that a book like Scarlet Spider wouldn’t have the constraints of a normal Spider-Man comic. Kaine is hardly an important, long-lasting character. His supporting cast will probably never be seen again. The villains he faces aren’t very important. I feel Yost should have had a lot more freedom to really push the envelope. Instead, we get a comic where that seems like it might be the case, but where Yost has to pull back at the last second.

What a shame. But it’s an even bigger shame that this comic is coming to an end soon.

Read the rest of this entry →